Now Reading
Stop poking the Russian bear

Stop poking the Russian bear

War between Russia and the West seems nearly inevitable. No self-respecting nation facing inexorable encirclement by an alliance of hostile neighbors can allow such pressures and forces to continue indefinitely. Eventually it must protect its interests through military action. Indeed, Russia already has resorted to military action: in Georgia in 2008, after that Russian neighbor initiated a war with Moscow designed to severely curtail Russia’s influence in its own neighborhood, and in eastern Ukraine, after the West encouraged and fostered a 2014 revolution that upended an elected Ukrainian leader whose foreign and economic policies tilted toward Russia.

And consider Russia’s territorial fate since the West’s Cold War victory over Soviet Bolshevism. Before that momentous development, which was entirely necessary and laudable, the Soviet Union had no Western enemies within a thousand miles of Leningrad. Now that fabled Russian city, renamed St. Petersburg once again after the obliteration of the ideological menace of Soviet communism, resides within a hundred miles of NATO military forces. Moscow was protected behind 1,200 miles of controlled territory during the Cold War; now that distance is two hundred miles.

This represents a monumental shift in Russia’s geopolitical situation, and much of it was, and remains, a cause of celebration. The Soviet yoke over the peoples of Eastern Europe had to be removed, and the West’s long Cold War struggle, particularly the early initiatives under Harry Truman and the final push under Ronald Reagan, represents a heroic tale of calibrated resistance and tireless resolve.

But Western intrusion into traditional Russian spheres of influence, areas under the sway of Moscow for three centuries or more, represents a highly provocative and destabilizing policy. Ukraine was one such Russian sphere of influence. Georgia was another. So was Belarus. So was Serbia. All have been subject to Western designs to one degree or another, including serious U.S. initiatives to dismember Serbia and get Georgia and Ukraine into NATO.

Further, the West has offered no expressions indicating what might be the limitations of its encirclement plans. Prominent Americans talk freely of “regime change” in the country, and the U.S. government has sponsored NGO activities designed to foment antigovernment activities there of the kind that stirred a pro-Russian leader of Ukraine—the corrupt but duly elected Viktor Yanukovych—to flee his own country upon threat of death. America’s promiscuous post–Cold War activities in support of regime change—in Iraq, Libya, Syria, Yemen—lend weight to suspicions that it harbors similar views toward Russian president Vladimir Putin.

Indeed, the demonization of Putin by America’s intelligentsia has been nearly unprecedented in peacetime. Hillary Clinton invokes Hitler as a comparative figure and, while others have stopped short of that kind of rhetorical excess, the attitude remains the same. He is evil and presides over a menacing, conquest-hungry nation; he and his country must be stopped, curtailed, declawed. There is no recognition in any of this that Russians may view themselves, with at least some validity, as a beleaguered nation vis-à-vis America and its allies.

Donald Trump was elected in part to change all that. As the University of Southern California’s Robert David English notes in his excellent recent Foreign Affairs essay, Trump repeatedly asserted in his first press conference that it would be “positive,” “good,” or “great” if “we could get along with Russia.” Unlike most of the country’s elites, he vowed to seek Moscow’s cooperation on global issues, accepted some U.S. share of blame for the two countries’ sour relations and acknowledged “the right of all nations to put their own interests first.”

This suggested a dramatic turn in U.S.-Russian relations—an end to the encirclement push, curtailment of the hostile rhetoric, a pullback on economic sanctions, and serious efforts to work with Russia on such nettlesome matters as Syria and Ukraine.

See Also

This budding initiative now lies in tiny shards upon the floor of global politics. We don’t yet know, and perhaps never will, the full story of what happened with regard to Russia’s effort to tilt America’s 2016 presidential election. And we can’t yet form a full picture of the actions undertaken on the part of the Trump team or the president himself to collude with official Russia in U.S. internal politics. It might be very serious; it might not.

But it almost doesn’t matter. Trump’s Russia initiative appears dead. The anti-Russian elites have won the day, whatever the merits of the case or wherever the facts now lead. The president looks hapless on the issue. New sanctions are coming, whether he wants them or not. NATO expansion and the West’s Ukraine meddling will continue. Encirclement is firmly in place.

It’s difficult to envision where this could lead, short of actual hostilities. Russia’s fundamental national interests, the ones Trump was prepared to accept, will almost certainly render such hostilities inevitable.

Originally appeared at The National Interest

Liked it? Take a second to support The Duran on Patreon!

25
Leave a Reply

avatar
7 Comment threads
18 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
12 Comment authors
Vera GottliebzorbatheturkVlad PufagtinenkoBessarabyndago dingo Recent comment authors
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Isabella Jones
Guest
Isabella Jones

“We don’t yet know, and perhaps never will, the full story of what happened with regard to Russia’s effort to tilt America’s 2016 presidential election.”

Yes, you do “know the full story”. President Putin, F.M. Lavrov and others have told you time and time again – you just dont want to listen, don’t want to believe it. There was NONE. NO Russian interference in the US election.
What part of that simple sentence is it that Americans are incapable of understanding??

FlorianGeyer
Guest
FlorianGeyer

I was just about to say the same as you so eloquently have.
Well done.

dave3200
Guest
dave3200

Me too. Well stated, Isabella.

Isabella Jones
Guest
Isabella Jones

Thankyou Florian

IanSeed
Guest
IanSeed

Ditto that! Must admit I was surprised to read the words you quoted in your first sentence.

Vera Gottlieb
Guest
Vera Gottlieb

Does the US really think it would come out victorious engaging Russia AND China? Does the US really believe China would quietly stand by and just let things happen? Not as immediate, but China is just as much at risk of being encircled.

Scott Robinson
Guest
Scott Robinson

Exactly my thoughts as I was coming to the comments – China is the key.

zorbatheturk
Guest
zorbatheturk

Da, Igor.

Vlad Pufagtinenko
Guest
Vlad Pufagtinenko

The US could wipe out China And Russia any time it wants. Why would it?
Russia is no threat, and China is still useful until Trump brings all the manufacturing jobs back to America.

Vera Gottlieb
Guest
Vera Gottlieb

Dreams of grandeur??? Russia and China together are a force that the US would never be able to stand up to, not even with the help of NATO. Both Russia and China don’t play poker, the play chess…i.e. a lot of thinking before action.

Vlad Pufagtinenko
Guest
Vlad Pufagtinenko

Will Russia be using the aircraft carrier they pull around with tugboats?
… or the tanks that don’t work at May Day parades?

Vera Gottlieb
Guest
Vera Gottlieb

And will the US/NATO be using the useless lemons called ‘F-35’ fighter jets??? Or perhaps have more destroyers run into oil tankers?

Vlad Pufagtinenko
Guest
Vlad Pufagtinenko

They found out that Russian diaspora transvestites were steering the American ships. So that problem should be over now that Trump signed that recent presidential order.
Are you upset about the fact that you won’t even see the F-35’s after they’ve destroyed the Kremlin?

Vera Gottlieb
Guest
Vera Gottlieb

Keep dreaming. Long before the Kremlin is ever destroyed, the American Empire will have imploded through self-destruction.

Vlad Pufagtinenko
Guest
Vlad Pufagtinenko

BAHAHAHA

Vera Gottlieb
Guest
Vera Gottlieb

Don’t forget…empires come, empires go. The American empire is on the way out. Thank goodness.

Vlad Pufagtinenko
Guest
Vlad Pufagtinenko

You keep hoping when you’re praying to your picture of shirtless Putin.

Vera Gottlieb
Guest
Vera Gottlieb

As I said…empires come and empires go…

zorbatheturk
Guest
zorbatheturk

Your RuSSian empire imploded a long time ago. Putin just hasn’t realised it yet.

Vera Gottlieb
Guest
Vera Gottlieb

You don’t seem to read much of the latest news, do you. The US is up to it’s eye balls in debt, social upheavals now worse under Trump, the entire infrastructure falling apart, a possible civil war in the making. Resembles more a Third World nation. Latest polls indicate that people around the world trust Russia more than the US – and that includes me.

Seán McGouran
Guest
Seán McGouran

The “ideological menace of Soviet ommunism…”? Wot? Soe people might agree with it? I only ask…. because I want to know…

englishvinal
Guest
englishvinal

I am not sure what lies behind the insane “Russians are Coming” fixation … we know it isn’t the inane, IQ 94 “mean-eyed media whores”.. both sexes. What a disgusting lot of sycophants… the brown ring around their mouths shows even through the 7 layers of stage makeup on their simpering faces… (those ARE faces right?)… that said (with great glee), they don’t THINK.. or HAVE opinions.. they regurgitate what their masters tell them… The result of this onslaught of endless “The Russians.. the russians the russians” …. serves to focus the minds of the masses on Russia, but not… Read more »

dago dingo
Guest
dago dingo

The real persons, or should I say, country dictating American foreign policy ( Israhell) is behind Trumps sudden reverse shift in foreign policy, and particularly with regards to Russia.

Bessarabyn
Guest
Bessarabyn

Is this the NYT or WaPo journalist doin a liberal spin ? or Ru’s 5th colon (!)

zorbatheturk
Guest
zorbatheturk

RuSSian bear has got advanced rabies.

Copyright DRN Media PLC 2019. RSS: http://theduran.com/feed

Scroll To Top